Last week, I ran across an article about a teenager in
Florida that was made to change her t-shirt after school officials determined
it violated the dress code. Summer
Schreiner, 15 wore a t-shirt to school which said, “Don’t drink and park. Accidents cause kids”. Schreiner received the shirt when she
attended “Silver Ring Thing” a Christian conference that asks teenagers to take
celibacy vows until they’re married.
Schreiner wore her t-shirt through lunch, until she was made by school
officials to change into a shirt given to her which read, “Tomorrow, I will
dress for success”.
The school’s dress code prohibits clothing which contains sexually explicit or oriented wording. Schreiner said her shirt promoted a positive message, and that sex is discussed in school as part of the curriculum for sex education. She says her abstinence vow is important to her, and that she felt humiliated by school officials. Michelle Irwin, Director of Communications for the school district stated, “This is not a situation of whether or not the district agrees or disagrees with abstinence among teens. It’s about the fact the she violated the dress code.”
This isn’t the first time I’ve read about students violating
school dress codes for what seems like pretty innocuous things. Check out this student who was told her
unnatural hair color violated the school’s dress code: http://www.inquisitr.com/520379/student-banned-from-school-for-unnatural-hair-color-is-allowed-back/ In October, 17 year old Zachary Aufderheide
was made to serve a two day in-school suspension because his hair length
violated the school’s dress code.
Aufderheide was growing out his hair to donate to the charity Locks of
Love.
I’m torn on the issue of dress codes for students. I generally detest censorship of any form, and I am generally suspicious of authority. That being said, I grew up poor and my parents didn’t always have the money to buy me the latest fashions. What made it worse was that I often received the knock off version of the latest fashion, which in my mind just made me stand out more. Perhaps had my school had a stricter dress code, or required uniforms this wouldn’t have been such an issue for me.
So my question to you this week is, “Do you think Schreiner’s shirt violated what the school states as its dress code policy? Do you think students should have stricter dress codes and/or uniforms?” Answers are due no later than Sunday, March 3rd, 2013.